Estimation: a number you can redo

level 2 · 25 min · test effort estimation

An estimate answers how much effort testing will take. “About ten days, give or take” is a guess: nobody can check it or knows how far off it may be. Four techniques give the number an origin.

The ratio applies to the current project the proportion measured in previous projects. Extrapolation projects what the first iterations measured. The three-point estimate combines the best case, the most likely and the worst, and also gives the deviation. Wideband Delphi gathers the team’s estimates and uses the discussion of the differences to converge.

Rule of thumb. Give the number an origin: the ratio or extrapolation when there is history, three-point or Delphi when there is not. Report the margin too, not just the value.

Read the estimate

A number with no origin does not help planning. Each technique below gives the number an origin that can be checked.

The team asked for an estimate to test the next release.

Answer received: “about ten days, give or take”.

Questions to ask the number

  • Where does the number come from: history, measurement or a guess?
  • How far can it vary up or down?
  • Did one person or the team estimate it?
  • If someone asks, can the calculation be redone?

Exercise: estimate with the right technique

In each situation, choose the correct calculation or decision. The techniques are the ratio with data from previous projects, extrapolation, the three-point estimate and Wideband Delphi.

RatioIn previous projects, every 5 days of development took 2 days of testing. This project has 30 days of development. How many days of testing?
ExtrapolationThe first three iterations took 6, 8 and 10 days of testing. 5 iterations remain. How many days of testing are left, keeping the average?
Three pointsThe best case is 6 days, the most likely is 9 and the worst is 18. What is the estimate E = (a + 4m + b) ÷ 6?
UncertaintyWith the same values (6, 9 and 18), what is the standard deviation SD = (b − a) ÷ 6?
Wideband DelphiThree people each estimated on their own: 4, 5 and 20 days. What does the team do?
Choosing the techniqueA new project with no similar history. Which technique do you use to estimate?

Choose one option for each situation.

References

  • ISTQB® Certified Tester Foundation Level v4.0, section 5.1, Test Planning. © ISTQB®.